Four Seats, One Alignment: US Crypto Regulation Enters the Lame-Duck Window

作者:

在

Four Seats, One Alignment: US Crypto Regulation Enters the Lame-Duck Window

Days after the midterms, the White House sent four SEC and CFTC commissioner nominations to the Senate on November 12, and the SEC filed an amicus brief backing the CFTC in the single-stock perpetuals lawsuit the same day. Who writes the rules, and how rules get challenged, both gained new answers in a single day.

Key Takeaways

On November 12, the White House sent four SEC and CFTC commissioner nominations to the Senate, one Republican and one Democrat per agency, including two CLARITY Act negotiators for the CFTC. The same day, the SEC filed an amicus brief backing the CFTC in the single-stock perpetuals lawsuit while reserving a 60-day review through December 31. With CLARITY stalled, commission composition and judicial review have become the twin variables of US crypto regulation, both running in parallel during the lame-duck window.

Four Nominations: An Insurance Design with One of Each Party

On November 12, the White House nomination notice sent four appointments to the Senate at once, covering two vacancies at each of the SEC and the CFTC. This is the first time since 2025 that the Trump administration has put forward nominees for the two agencies, and the first time it has placed Democrats on either panel.

At the SEC: Democrat Kristin N. Johnson (Michigan) was nominated for the seat left by Caroline Crenshaw, with a term ending June 5, 2029; Republican Steven Levine (Maryland) was nominated for the seat left by Hester Peirce, with a term ending June 5, 2030. At the CFTC: Republican Nathan Anonick (Virginia) was nominated to succeed Rostin Behnam, with a term ending June 19, 2031; Democrat Matthew Rowland (District of Columbia) was nominated to succeed Summer Mersinger, serving the remainder of a term ending April 13, 2028.

“Two strong bipartisan picks.”
— CFTC Chairman Mike Selig on X, November 12, 2026

All four resumes point directly at crypto regulation. Johnson, a former CFTC commissioner appointed by Joe Biden, repeatedly spoke at the CFTC about crypto custody, DeFi and AI regulation, and now moves from an insider view of a regulated agency to the SEC. Levine, a senior official at the White House Council of Economic Advisers, previously served as counsel and deputy chief of staff to SEC Commissioner Mark Uyeda. More telling are the two CFTC nominees: Anonick is senior counsel on the Senate Agriculture Committee, the panel that oversees the CFTC, and helped spearhead the committee’s portion of the CLARITY Act; Rowland is a CFTC attorney detailed to that committee who once worked on Johnson’s staff and also worked on the CLARITY Act. Two people who personally negotiated the US market-structure bill are about to enter the agencies that would implement market-structure rules.

Timing is the real story. Republicans lost the Senate in the November 3 midterms and will hand over the majority in January 2027. The nominations must clear Senate confirmation during the current Republican-controlled lame-duck window, or they will be handed to the incoming Democratic Senate, where committee processes, hearing schedules and political incentives all shift. The one-of-each pairing is insurance designed for exactly this reality: both parties have their own people on the list, so neither side has a reason to hold up the package.

Agency Nominee Party Replacing Term ends
SEC Kristin N. Johnson Democrat Caroline Crenshaw 2029-06-05
SEC Steven Levine Republican Hester Peirce 2030-06-05
CFTC Nathan Anonick Republican Rostin Behnam 2031-06-19
CFTC Matthew Rowland Democrat Summer Mersinger 2028-04-13

After the CLARITY Act failed 49-50 on September 15, market-structure legislation at the congressional level has frozen. The consequence of a stalled legislative path is that the composition of the SEC and CFTC commissions has itself become a policy decision, because commissioners vote on rules, enforcement cases and product approvals. The SEC currently has only two commissioners (Chair Paul Atkins and Uyeda) and changed its rules in October to allow a single commissioner to form a quorum; CFTC Chair Selig is the agency’s only sitting commissioner. Four confirmed seats would restore both agencies from minority decision-making to near-full strength.

For the market, the policy direction after confirmation matters more than the names. The CFTC is drafting a framework for leveraged retail crypto trading and has argued that offshore exchanges should face federal registration and cybersecurity rules, with Selig tying that position directly to the $6.3 billion Binance hack in October. The SEC, meanwhile, decides which crypto products reach US investors and how aggressively the industry is policed. Once both nominees are confirmed, the CFTC will have more than one person making decisions for the first time, and SEC rulemaking such as Regulation Crypto Assets will gain additional commissioner support.

The SEC Sides with the CFTC: A Contested Approval and a December 31 Red Line

On the same day, the SEC filed an amicus brief in Capital Markets Alliance Association v. CFTC (No. 1:26-cv-09608-LGS) in federal court in Manhattan, supporting the CFTC’s approval of single-stock perpetual futures. The position is the opposite of the picture painted by the plaintiff.

Background: On September 18, Coinbase Derivatives, KalshiEx and Bitnomial (owned by Kraken parent Payward), three exchanges registered with both the CFTC and the SEC, submitted rule-change requests to list “equity perpetuals,” a cash-settled derivative with no expiry date that uses recurring funding payments to keep the contract price aligned with the underlying stock. The CFTC’s review window lapsed on November 2 and the contracts were “deemed approved”; Chair Selig issued a statement on November 3 announcing that the contracts could begin trading for the first time on CFTC-registered exchanges. The Capital Markets Alliance Association (CMA), a trade group whose members include Cboe and Citadel Securities, immediately sued, arguing the products are security-based swaps that belong under the SEC’s exclusive jurisdiction, and that the CFTC’s approval violated the Administrative Procedure Act without explaining its reasoning.

“By approving these products for trading without a word explaining how its action comports with the statutory framework, the CFTC has permitted an end-run around Congress’s deliberate statutory protections and invited a parallel, synthetic market in U.S. stocks to grow outside the exclusive jurisdiction of the SEC.”
— Capital Markets Alliance Association, complaint, November 2026

The SEC responded in its brief: “That depiction—of a CFTC gone rogue, and an SEC gone missing—is mistaken.” The SEC stressed that CFTC rule changes remain subject to SEC review, that the two agencies collaborate frequently on “issues of common regulatory interest,” and that defining a product as a security future “does not create an end-run around the regulatory regime.” The SEC said it holds “substantial” enforcement and regulatory authority over security futures, including enforcing the central fraud, manipulation and insider-trading prohibitions of the federal securities laws, overseeing the intermediaries that handle security futures transactions, and setting the rules governing their ongoing trading.

But the SEC did not answer the central question: are these contracts futures or swaps? The SEC said that because the CFTC’s approval triggered a 60-day SEC review period running through December 31, 2026, “the SEC respectfully takes no position in this brief on whether the rule changes should be abrogated.” Within those 60 days, if the SEC finds the rule change “unduly burdens competition or efficiency, conflicts with the securities laws, or is inconsistent with the public interest and the protection of investors,” it can abrogate the change and send it back for ordinary notice-and-approval procedures.

Early signals in the litigation are mixed. On November 3, Judge Valerie Caproni denied the CMA’s request for a temporary restraining order but found the association likely to succeed on its claim that the CFTC lacks the relevant authority, noting that perpetual contracts never provide for delivery of the underlying shares at a future date, making them look like swaps under the SEC’s remit. The case has since been reassigned to Judge Lorna Schofield, with oral argument on the preliminary injunction not yet scheduled and the CFTC’s answer due November 25. The market is voting with its feet: Kalshi began offering contracts on roughly 50 US stocks and ETFs on November 5, Cboe told the court its second-day 24-hour notional volume was approximately $375 million, and Plus500 began offering Kalshi perpetuals to institutional clients in October.

The most dramatic demonstration came overnight. After The Wall Street Journal reported that Nvidia’s board was preparing to oust CEO Jensen Huang, Nvidia perpetuals on Hyperliquid, the venue’s largest traditional-asset market by open interest, fell as much as about 10% overnight to roughly $156, closely matching the stock’s after-hours low; tokenized Nvidia shares traded on crypto venues fell as much as 9%. While US cash markets were closed, the perpetuals completed 24-hour price discovery. Supporters call it round-the-clock price discovery; critics call it leveraged single-stock trading in thin hours on venues outside the securities regime.

The amicus lineup splits along business lines: Coinbase, Kalshi and Payward joined DRW, Jump Trading and Paradigm in backing the CFTC; Better Markets, former SEC acting chair Allison Herren Lee and former SEC general counsel John Coates back the CMA, arguing the products “are in fact securities swaps,” that leverage of roughly 6x means “an investor’s entire portfolio can be zeroed out with just a 16% movement in the market,” and that the CFTC is “attempting to gut 90 years of investor protections.” CME Group, which has been suing the CFTC over bitcoin perpetuals since June, and five securities law scholars also applied to file briefs. The court has accepted two briefs supporting the CFTC, with at least two supporting the alliance awaiting permission.

The two events converging on the same day is no coincidence. Nominations decide who sits at the rulemaking table; litigation decides whether approved rules survive. Together they sketch the real operating mode of US crypto regulation after CLARITY failed: administrative rules keep advancing, but every step can be challenged in court, rewritten by new commissioners, and compressed by the lame-duck clock.

Takeaways for Practitioners

1
Commission composition and judicial review are the twin constraints on the administrative path
With CLARITY frozen, SEC/CFTC commission membership and court rulings have replaced Congress as policy variables. Confirmation determines the rulemaking pace for years to come, and the single-stock perpetuals case will draw the boundary between “security futures” and “security-based swaps.” Firms assessing US regulatory risk should weight these two variables alongside the rule texts.

2
The lame-duck window is a high-density period for institutional change
From November 12 to January 2027, eight weeks form the window for Senate confirmation of this slate. Whatever the outcome, the SEC/CFTC commission structure a year from now will differ from today. The key nodes of regulatory competition are often personnel days, not rule publication days.

3
The “rules vacuum” around perpetuals keeps product-shape risk high
The SEC holds abrogation authority through December 31, and the court has not yet ruled on the preliminary injunction, so the products keep trading in a state of regulatory uncertainty. Institutions involved in US equity perpetuals or similar no-expiry derivatives should treat December 31 and the court ruling as two observation points for product survival.

4
“24-hour price discovery” is becoming a live case study in regulatory disputes
The overnight Nvidia perpetuals tape shows both sides: price discovery continues while cash markets are closed, but leverage, thin hours and off-regime venues coexist. The legitimacy debate over this “overnight pricing” will shape the regulatory path of both tokenized securities and perpetual derivatives.

评论

发表回复

您的邮箱地址不会被公开。 必填项已用 * 标注