USDC Flips USDT in Euro Trading as UK and EU Carve Payment Rights by Issuer

USDC Flips USDT in Euro Trading as UK and EU Carve Payment Rights by Issuer

The EU filters stablecoins through compliance costs while the UK cuts payment eligibility by license category, pushing dollar coins off the payment rails on both tracks.

USDC euro trading share
56%
Kaiko Nov 6, overtakes USDT

EBA significant EMT
USDC
First · direct oversight since Nov 12

FCA authorisation applications
0
54 pre-auth meetings, 92 requests

Qivalis member banks
37
BNP Paribas · ING · UniCredit

Two regulatory tracks running in parallel across Europe in November point to the same outcome. In the EU, Kaiko data shows USDC has reached a 56% share of euro-denominated stablecoin trading, overtaking USDT for the first time, as MiCA compliance requirements push market makers and institutional order flow toward Circle. In the UK, the FCA’s CP26/36 draft, published October 21, cuts payment activities involving locally qualifying stablecoins out of the crypto licensing regime, while overseas-issued USDC and USDT stay inside the full framework. Both routes are reallocating stablecoin payment eligibility through regulatory definitions, and the eligibility boundary happens to run along the issuer’s place of incorporation.

Why it matters

Two consultation windows are closing at the same time this week. The European Commission’s MiCA review consultation closed on September 30 and ESMA’s response is public. The FCA’s CP26/36 consultation closes November 18, with final guidance due in January or spring next year. Both proposals touch the most central question about stablecoins: who gets to do payments, and who is left with investing.

For practitioners, that question matters more than exchange-rate moves. Once payment eligibility is written into the rules, the issuer’s location becomes part of the business model, and the uniformity of cross-border stablecoins gets split along regulatory boundaries.

Where things stand

The EU track runs on compliance cost. MiCA requires stablecoin issuers to hold an electronic money institution (EMI) license in the EEA. Circle secured licenses for both USDC and EURC in France; Tether declined to apply, objecting to mandatory bank reserve requirements. The result is that Kraken, Bitstamp and OKX have systematically restricted non-compliant stablecoin pairs, and market makers and institutional money flow to compliant coins. The EBA designated USDC the EU’s first significant e-money token on October 14, and since November 12 its reserves, liquidity and redemption plans are directly supervised by the EBA, sharing oversight with France’s ACPR.

The UK track cuts by license category. CP26/36 proposes two exclusions: payment firms transferring a UK qualifying stablecoin do not need a crypto dealing or arranging permission, and holding one temporarily to execute a payment does not require a crypto safeguarding permission. The test hinges on the issuer’s permission. Proposed PERG 18.4.5A defines a UK qualifying stablecoin as one issued by a firm holding permission under the UK issuing activity; Circle’s USDC and Tether’s USDT, issued abroad, stay fully inside the crypto licensing framework. A UK-authorised issuer could even issue a dollar coin that qualifies, because currency plays no part in the definition. The issuer’s location decides everything.

The FCA’s pre-authorisation numbers pour cold water on the practical side. Since May 11, the FCA has met 54 crypto firms for pre-application meetings and received 92 meeting requests, rejecting 18 where firms were only seeking compliance or legal advice. Since the application gateway opened on September 30, formal authorisation applications stand at zero; only two FSMA-authorised firms have applied for a variation of permission. Under the old MLR regime, 408 firms applied for registration and 69 were registered, of which 20 are now under restrictions.

Deeper analysis

The two routes differ in a way worth unpacking. The EU filters by compliance cost, and what gets filtered out is issuers who refuse to cooperate, but the winner left standing is still a dollar coin: USDC’s overtake of USDT is not a victory for euro stablecoins, it is Circle trading compliance for American asset substitution. The UK cuts by license category, giving locally issued coins a payment fast lane on paper, but zero applications show the industry is not rushing in, because the rules themselves are still drafts and firms are making business decisions against draft law while waiting for final guidance.

One level deeper is the reserve-structure divergence. MiCA requires stablecoin reserves to sit inside the banking system; the US GENIUS Act allows reserves to be invested in government debt. That structural difference leaves euro stablecoins short one revenue leg by design. Qivalis, the 37-bank euro stablecoin consortium backed by BNP Paribas, ING and UniCredit, proposes a synthetic safe asset, investing reserves in European money market instruments to route around the absence of a unified euro-area bond market. The UK Treasury’s payment modernisation reforms are not finished either; CP26/36’s exclusions are a bridge, and the full regime does not take effect until 2027.

Supervisory power is also being re-sorted. In the MiCA review, the Commission and ESMA discussed moving authorisation and supervision of large CASPs from member states to ESMA; on October 9 the Council narrowed it to significant providers only, under a test of 15 million active users or three of five further criteria, with an estimated 10 to 15 of roughly 360 authorised providers qualifying. France’s Treasury, AMF, Banque de France and ACPR jointly proposed simplifying the rulebook, recognising that the ART category has been hollowed out, building a framework for multi-issuer stablecoins and pulling DeFi inside the regulatory perimeter.

Investment view

Market data cuts both ways. OneBullEx data from November 14 shows dollar stablecoins taking 99.1% of stablecoin order-book volume, while euro-denominated trading holds an 11.8% share across a basket of 33 fiat currencies. USDC’s euro share went from zero to 56% inside a very small pool; the euro stablecoin market is still several orders of magnitude away from replacing the dollar. Circle generated $1.4 billion in revenue in the first half of the year but paid $819 million to distribution partners and transaction costs, keeping about 7 cents of net profit per revenue dollar. Compliance-heavy asset models are not a high-margin business.

For private markets, the signal is that issuer location is becoming a financing variable. The UK issuing permission takes effect in October 2027 and the application window closes February 28, 2027; whoever holds a UK license gets the payment fast lane, and overseas issuers face a choice between setting up a UK entity or partnering with licensed distributors. Qivalis’s 37 banks are the clearest direction of supply-side capital, and infrastructure investment in euro stablecoins is starting to build.

Consumer and user view

User-facing change is lagging but underway. After EU exchanges delisted USDT pairs, retail trading choices narrowed automatically, and compliant replacements required no active learning. In the UK, payment firms moving UK qualifying stablecoins will not need crypto permissions, but the rules are not in force yet, so users feel nothing for now. Visa’s stablecoin settlement is running at a $25 billion annualized pace and Western Union’s Stablecard covers 37 markets; the user-side rails are being laid, and stablecoins as payment tools are becoming invisible.

Conclusion: opportunities

One direction is the UK issuing permission, with the application window closing February 28, 2027. A license means automatic access to the payment fast lane after October 2027, the clearest institutional dividend on the table. Another is euro stablecoin reserve structure: Qivalis’s synthetic safe asset solves Europe’s missing unified bond market, and whoever works out reserve yield first fills the euro coin’s weakest leg. The centralisation of supervision toward ESMA will reshuffle compliance costs, and the list of the 10 to 15 qualifying institutions is itself the competitive order for the next phase.

Key signal: Stablecoin payment eligibility is being redrawn along issuer location. The EU uses compliance costs to let Circle eat USDT’s euro share, the UK uses license categories to route locally issued coins into payments past the crypto regime, and dollar coins are being pushed off the payment track on both lines. Issuer location becomes part of the stablecoin business model, and cross-border coin uniformity is split along regulatory boundaries.
1
Compliance cost rewrites market structureMiCA’s EMI license requirement kept Tether out of Europe, Kraken, Bitstamp and OKX delisted non-compliant pairs, and USDC took 56% of euro volume. This is not a euro coin victory; it is Circle’s compliance bought with American asset substitution.

2
The UK cuts payment eligibility by issuer locationCP26/36 lets UK qualifying stablecoins bypass dealing permission for payments, while USDC and USDT stay in the full framework because they are issued abroad. The same licensed issuer can even issue a dollar coin that qualifies; currency is irrelevant, location decides.

3
Industry waits for rules instead of rushingThe FCA held 54 pre-authorisation meetings but received zero formal applications. Nobody races to make business decisions against draft law; final guidance lands in January or spring, and the regime begins in October 2027.

4
Reserve structure decides coin competitivenessMiCA requires reserves in banks, GENIUS allows treasuries, leaving euro coins short one yield leg. Qivalis plugs the gap with a synthetic safe asset, and its 37-bank consortium is the clearest supply-side capital direction.

评论

发表回复

您的邮箱地址不会被公开。 必填项已用 * 标注